Comparison review: Comparing various types of trekking poles [For hiking, snowy mountains, trail running]

A subtle power that is essential for a comfortable hike

Over the past decades, trekking poles have become an indispensable part of comfortable hiking. As mentioned in the previous article, " How to Choose a Trekking Pole That You Don't Regret, " trekking poles are an under-reliance that supports walking in various ways during activities, such as clues when climbing, reducing impact on descending, and maintaining balance when crossing.

Basically, it would be helpful if it were a "stand" with a certain thickness and length, but as you delve into its performance and functionality, the performance required depending on the expected activity, the load, and the terrain used, etc., becomes increasingly complicated. Although it's just a cane, a deep world quickly expands.

This time we'll be comparing these trekking poles thoroughly. We've picked out models that stand out in terms of popularity, performance, price, etc., and as usual, we'll compare them on actual mountain climbs, evaluating and comparing performance from various angles. Let's take a look now.

table of contents

• About the items we compared and tested this time
• Test results and spec comparison table
• Evaluation results - Recommended trekking poles by type
• Detailed reviews of each item (Page: 2)
• Summary (Page:2)

About the trekking poles compared this time

When selecting candidates for comparison, the following criteria were roughly considered:

• A model that allows mountain climbing and trekking
• Excluding models exclusive to walking and running
• The length can be adjusted around 120cm.
• Available to purchase from authorized Japanese distributors
• Selected mainly from popular brands among climbers (reference on Yamakei Online's " Brand Image & Climbing Equipment Purchasing Trends Survey 2016 ")

However, if you simply choose a popular model, the manufacturer and type will inevitably be biased, so this time we narrowed down the candidate models, taking into consideration the above conditions, in order to create variations in pole material, locking method, connection method, price range, etc. Furthermore, after looking at the actual models at the store, we narrowed down the nine points that we could compare this time. Of course, it's not that there are absolutely no personal interests or preferences, but I would like to make sure that at least the candidates listed here are definitely recommended models that meet certain standards at the time.

Test environment

The test period was approximately one year from summer 2016 to August 2017, and I gradually purchased it rather than a horizontal line, and continued to use the ones I had on hand. We have conducted several tests using all poles under the same conditions, and in this case we have compared them and evaluated them by the author himself and several other acquaintances who are currently climbing to beginners to improve our accuracy. In the surrounding area of ​​Tokyo, in the mountains of Okuchichibu, Yatsugatake, and Joshinetsu (around 1,000-2,500m), some models were used in snowy mountains, with some models being used in snowy mountains.

In this comparison test, the following six items are evaluated as indicators: The importance of each item is explained to some extent in " How to Choose a Trekking Pole ", so if you would like to know more, please refer to this as well.

• "Comfort" and "weight" such as ease of grip and less stress when walking
• "Fixing & Adjustment" and "Storageability" that affect ease of use and safety
• "Durability" is essential for long-term, safe use
• "Vernability" in terms of whether it can be used for a wide range of seasons, terrain, and activities

The evaluation figures for the test results are based solely on the judgment of the evaluator who conducted the test. We aim to achieve an objective and convincing evaluation as much as possible, but please use this as a reference when considering that it is impossible to eliminate subjective evaluations such as comfort and fit, and that disagreements about this point are of course possible.

Test results and spec comparison table

Prices are displayed for reference based on the prices of the official online store as of August 2017.

Evaluation results - Recommended trekking poles by type

LEKI Micro Vario Carbon AS

Overall 1st place: There is no word "compromise" and no matter how you look at it, it's a top-class piece

Micro Vario Carbon AS , the flagship model of LEKI, one of the world's leading pole manufacturers in trekking and winter sports, has ranked first in this overall rating.

It's certainly not a surprising lighter one. However, the combination of a carbon shaft and an aluminum connection part makes it a structure that does not have gaps in both strength and flexibility while maintaining its lightness. The comfortable grip made from an ergonomic, easy-to-grip shape and non-slip material provided the most comfortable grip on both climbing and descent. In particular, the LEKI's unique grip shape, which can be held over the top of the grip, with a palm, made it so comfortable that many addicts were addict.

Other reasons why it should be number one, such as the moderate thrust comfort of the Dynamic Suspension System, which reduces impact from the ground, the ease of use of the Speed ​​Lock 2 System, a lever lock that combines operability, fixed force, and adjustability, and the durability of the wire part that connects the poles. Of course, there is also an optional snow basket that can be used on the snow surface, so there is no problem with its versatility.

The only problem is the price. Given this price, performance may be as expected. However, while there are some items in the world that show so-called subjective aspects such as design and status in price, this model is clearly the best in terms of performance and functionality, and it is an item that we can confidently recommend to anyone as the No. 1 item.

Black Diamond Alpine Carbon Cork

No. 1 in comfort, perfect for those who want to use it safely and for a long time even on harsh mountain climbs

Alpine Carbon Cork , a carbon all-round model from Black Diamond, a major brand that is on par with LEKI as an outdoor pole maker, was not ranked number one overall in terms of overall rating, but it was definitely one of my favorite poles in this comparison.

Our top recommendation is that the cork grip makes it comfortable to stock. The grips made of EVA foam, which is currently the mainstream grip material, are very comfortable these days, but cork has been stable and non-slip even when wet with sweat or rain, regardless of when it is dry. It also has goodness that can only be produced in cork, with moderate elasticity and subtle warmth and natural texture. Although the grip itself is not extremely ergonomic, I felt that the grip, which is not too thick or too thin, is very curved, is very easy to grip under normal use and is well thought out.

Another notable feature is the stability when you thrust the pole while walking. Poles made of easily bendable materials such as poles with a thin shaft diameter or aluminum may be a concern when they hit the ground, but this model is made of carbon and has a shaft with a maximum diameter of 18mm, which is the thickest of all the comparisons we have seen, making it extremely stable. This comfortable thrusts during actions is one of the major points that makes this model the No. 1 comfort. On the other hand, it is heavy for carbon, so it may not be suitable for people who want it lighter than carbon, or for those who want to use it for trail running.

Black Diamond Distance Carbon FLZ

Top class lightness for speed hiking

Trekking poles, which directly convey the weight of the tool through the handle, are tools that are easily influenced by subtle differences in weight compared to other mountain tools. However, if you make it too light, it cannot be used for mountain climbing carrying luggage, so it is necessary to have a balance that is comfortable to use for trekking and is light. From this perspective, the Black Diamond Distance Carbon FLZ is the model that earned the highest points in the "Comfort + Weight" category in this comparison.

The top-class lightness of 300 grams can be combined with two, plus a grip that is easy to grip, a shaft that is durable enough for mountain climbing, and a lever locking system that is easy to operate and has a length adjustable lever lock method that is not only light, but also easy to use, which is a major attraction that other ultra-lightweight models do not have. We are very grateful for the careful construction and ingenuity that are packed with details to ensure that this is carried out.

This high-level lightness and storage capacity make it ideal for trail running and fast packing, and is perfect for full-scale climbing, making it a model that can be used without any problems, but the only problem is that the basket at the tip is fixed, so it cannot be replaced with a basket for the snow surface. Unfortunately, it cannot be used on snowy mountains. You need to be prepared to accept that you use it as hard as you can in a snow-free scene, but it is certainly the quality that will respond to that. the Distance Carbon Z , a model with almost the same specifications and length cannot be adjusted, can be further lighter.

SINANO Folder FREE 125

Achieves high lightness and compactness all seasons, including winter mountains

Comfort and durability are somewhat subjective, but the weight and storage size are even more severe than those. It's not an exaggeration to say that a lighter 10g or a shorter 1cm will change the world, and I can really understand the feelings of those who are particular about it. SINANO Folder FREE 125 is recommended for those who are pursuing such lightweight and compactness

In addition to being ultra-lightweight at about 400 grams, the highly storage capacity is a huge advantage, and while maintaining the limit of durability, the carbon shaft is extremely lightweight and boasts reliable strength to withstand serious mountain climbing. The fixed method is a screw lock rather than a lever lock, so there is little protrusion on the side, making it slim, making it surprisingly compact inside the backpack.

It can also be replaced with a basket for snow surfaces, and has an extension grip that allows you to hold it short and hike up even on steep slopes, making it perfect for use in snowy mountains. The stone thrust cap used on paved roads and wooden paths that may affect vegetation is also designed to be slip-resistant and difficult to fall, making it useful for all-round purposes regardless of season or terrain.

There are some concerns about durability, such as the ease of the wires connected to the wires and the likelihood of the screw lock breaking down, but it is true that this ease of use is easily adapted to in a variety of situations, and was extremely popular. From a broad perspective, it can be said to be a cost-effective model.

KOMPERDELL Wild Rambler

The most cost-effective value for money despite the minimal functionality

We have selected KOMPERDELL Wild Rambler for the No. 1 cost performance Looking at the internet, there are many trekking poles that are extremely cheap, around 1,000 yen, but to be honest, they're completely crafted, so even if they break in no time, you can't complain. Even if you can't spend too much money, you should at least choose a product from a solid mountain climbing brand.

Among them, the basic model made by KOMPERDELL, a global pole specialist manufacturer and OEM from another brand, is simple to make and to be honest, each part is poor, but the minimum comfort and stability when taking action is impressive. The polyethylene grip is slightly slippery when gripped with bare hands, but it won't bother you with gloves on. If you take into consideration this ingenuity, this price would be quite attractive (it actually sells even cheaper). In this comparison, if I were to choose a trekking pole for the first time, I would rather pay double the price for a little easier grip and adjustment ( KOMPERDELL Explorer Compact Power Lock ), then to be honest, I felt that this model would be enough for the first time.

If you're planning on trying out poles, or if you're not yet sure which one to choose, we recommend this model, which is comfortable, durable, and versatile, which will meet the needs of most people.

Next page: Go to detailed reviews of each item

Detailed reviews of each item

Comfort and weight

There is very little doubt that "more comfortable walking" is the most important point for trekking poles. However, it may be difficult for everyone to agree on what Paul should make it comfortable.

The editorial department first breaks down the elements that make up the comfort of a trekking pole into three perspectives: the grip material and shape (easiness to grip), the strap, and how the pole fits on the ground, and has compiled the evaluations of each of them as a comfort category. Another particularly important element of comfort is "weight," which is an independent evaluation item.

The Black Diamond Alpine Carbon Cork has a cork grip that is non-slip and fits well in your hands, a soft strap around it, and a sturdy and stable feel, making it the pole I felt was the most comfortable to use. In the Black Diamond Distance Carbon FLZ is also the light weight of about 350g, which reduces the stress of walking to the limit. The LEKI Micro Vario Carbon AS uses ergonomics to make it the most comfortable grip and overall lightness, both of which are well-balanced. These three models are superior or inferior for convenience, but in terms of overall comfort, both are difficult to match, and in reality, each person will find their likes and dislikes depending on how they are used and their tastes.

Grip material

Although the evaluation of grip materials differed slightly from model to model, "cork" and "EVA foam" were generally favored by all testers. To repeat, the high grip and comfort of the cork have a unique charm that can only be achieved with natural materials. It is also said that corks are generally more durable and last longer than EVA, but even after using EVA grips for just over a year, there are not many scratches. I think this depends on how you use it. On the other hand, many people did not appreciate rubber because of its ease of rubbing and the discomfort when wet. However, since it does not absorb water in cold regions, there is no need to worry about freezing, so it has an advantage over other materials. Finally, although polyethylene (plastics) is inexpensive and hygienic (and there is no need to worry about freezing), it is not suitable for intense activities or for long-term use, as it generally slips quite a bit, deteriorates over time, and is not suitable for use intensive activities.

The thickness of the grip

I didn't notice it until I actually compared it, but the grip thickness of the poles varies slightly depending on the manufacturer or model. the Black Diamond Distance Carbon FLZ , the SINANO Folder FREE 125 , the Helinox FL120, all had thin grips (23-24mm), while KOMPERDELL were thick (about 29mm) that would make them feel a bit bulky for people with small hands. It wasn't an extreme effect on the evaluation, but it seems that there will be some impact as female testers were very rated by the Helinox FL120, which I felt wasn't quite right. It's a good idea to take care when choosing.

weight

The Helinox FL120 weighs almost 300g , is undoubtedly the top lightweight rating. What's more, carbon has been considered to be advantageous in terms of lightweight properties, but it's surprising that aluminum is so light. This model, which is lightweight, compact, highly durable, and low-priced, is one of the best ways to enjoy trail running activities in this comparison. On the other hand, it seemed to have been somewhat difficult to understand overall comfort, such as the very thin and simple grip and the magnitude of vibration when thrusts with the ultra-fine shaft. An effective way to use this pole is to use it in a way that is completely unsatisfied.

Overall, there seems to be a boundary line that makes it seem "light" about whether or not it costs less than 400 grams. In that sense, the SINANO Folder FREE 125 has a strong impression of being a particularly light pole, and as it gets further, the weight difference will only be felt in the 50 gram increments.

Fixed and adjustable functions

As explained in Pole There are various ways to fix and adjust the pole depending on the purpose and price range Unlike the screw lock method, which requires a certain amount of grip strength each time to tighten it tightly, even those with low strength can easily and securely securely. In addition, the length can be adjusted and is less likely to break down, so the recent advanced lever locks are generally excellent for models from all manufacturers.

Among the lever locking methods of various manufacturers, the Speed ​​Lock 2 System installed in the LEKI Micro Vario Carbon AS Moreover, since it is foldable, the bottom can be pinned with just one touch, allowing for quick settings. By the way, the fixing force is also very easy to use, without the need for a screwdriver.

The screw locking system is not only a hassle to tighten, but also has a negative evaluation of the fact that it is sometimes too tight and stops moving, or the lock system breaks down and cannot be fixed. The only advantage that can be said to be the case is that the poles are not overhanging, making them easy to store, but the reality is that the recent compactness of locking systems has become a concern for mood.

Storageability

The storage capacity of a pole can be said to be almost the same as the connecting method of the pole. From this perspective, three models the SINANO Folder FREE 125 , LEKI Micro Vario Carbon AS , and Black Diamond Distance Carbon FLZ All of these are less than 40cm in storage size, so you can safely store them in your backpack. In particular, the SINANO Folder FREE 125 is 36cm tall, so it's hard to find a pole that can be stored so compactly even when looking around the world.

However, there was one thing to note about this storage capacity. Folding poles are great for storing in the main compartment or side of a backpack, but the compactness of the pole attachments that are attached to the front of the backpack, or the active pole attachments that come with the pack, such as Osprey, can cause the compactness of the pole attachments that can't be installed (or is difficult to install). I hope that backpack manufacturers will soon be able to deal with this issue, but at the moment, we need to be careful.

Durability

When it comes to pole durability, you tend to focus on the material of the shaft. However, although aluminum generally has the characteristic of being easy to bending but not easily folding, carbon is easy to break but is less likely to bend, the reality is that it is not possible to make a simple comparison of which material is stronger. For this reason, we do not evaluate the differences in strength depending on the material in detail here, but rather compare the durability of the entire item, mainly the shaft thickness (weight), the connection structure, and the ease of breaking of each part.

As a result of comparison, the KOMPERDELL Explorer Compact Power Lock has a larger shaft diameter than other poles, and each part is also sturdy. As a result, there are no very clever parts and it is a very basic construction. Other Black Diamond Alpine Carbon Cork has also been found to have the highest overall durability, with a thick shaft diameter and cork used for the grip. However, despite its relatively lightweight carbon, it is so heavy that it loses the goodness of the carbon of about 500g.

Versatility

Not only can trekking poles be adapted to a wide range of activities, seasons and terrain by attaching (replacing) optional parts, but this item evaluates the wide range of options. Specifically, there are size adjustments, whether or not there is a basket option for snow surfaces, whether or not there is an anti-slip cap for paved roads and wooden roads, and whether or not there is an extension grip for steep slopes.

These abundance of options are three : the LEKI Micro Vario Carbon AS , the Black Diamond Alpine Carbon Cork , and the SINANO Folder FREE 125 All of these models are top-notch in terms of price. On the other hand, the lowest priced KOMPERDELL Wild Rambler has no options other than size adjustment and snow basket options, so it may be a bit difficult to use on any course other than a typical one. This also shows that the higher-end models have a wide range of options and are easier to use all-around.

 

summary

Judging from the overall rating alone, we once again learned through the test that trekking poles are either cheap or bad to a very high degree, meaning that the price and ranking are generally proportional. Due to the nature of the items, there are no differences in design, so it seems that functions (performance) and price are inevitably linked directly.

However, if you have a specific purpose you want to prioritize, it is best to use it in detail accordingly. distance carbon FLZ for hiking in three seasons , Helinox FL120 Micro Vario Carbon AS for full-scale climbing Alpine Carbon Cork for snowy mountains . On the other hand, even for models in the mid-price range, it has been discovered that manufacturers have strengths and weaknesses in terms of the type of grip, durability, and ease of use. are LEKI or KOMPERDELL for comfort , Helinox LEKI for locking mechanism KOMPERDELL for durability Montbell for cost performance , so these trends are useful when choosing a model that suits your taste.

For better or worse, this time the test focuses on classic trekking pole models. It is true that there are many better (pointed) models that were not included in this test. We will also be covering these in future reviews, but if you look at them from the same perspective, it will help you decide whether the model is the right choice for you, so please take a look at it.

We also recommend this article about trekking poles.

• How to choose a trekking pole that you won't regret
• weight? function? price? 7 recommended trekking poles by type
• Review: Black Diamond Distance Carbon FLZ