Comparative review: Don't lose to distance. Don't be afraid of rough roads. Comparing trail running shoes for long distances

On the previous page, we introduced a ranking of the models we compared, a list of ratings and specs, and recommendations based on them. From here, we will explain what criteria were used to evaluate the evaluation, and why it was evaluated in that way.

Detailed reviews of each item

Comfort

The Terraultra G 260 offers a great balance of comfort . Thanks to the vertical and horizontal slits in the outer sole, it allows for a smooth run, and combined with the zero drop, it feels like you're running barefoot and in comfort. The Speedgoat 3 Caldorado III also offers a good balance of hold and sole flexibility, providing stress-free comfort. Of the five types, Caldorado III the best, suggesting its high breathability.

weight

The Terraultra G 260 weighs just 260g, making it very light both in weight and when riding. This weight is considered quite light for a long-distance model. When riding, the Speedgoat 3 feels even lighter than its actual weight. This is likely due to the Meta Rocker Geometry, which curves up on the forefoot of the sole, making for a lighter ride. the Momentus is 283g, but the actual measurement was 339g, which is quite a far cry, and the weight felt about right when riding.

grip

The Speedgoat 3 Momentus with Vibram MegaGrip and the Terraulttra G 260 . The grip of these three pairs gives me a sense of security. I can place my feet with confidence even on downhills. However, the MegaGrip is less durable than the G-Grip, so I've deducted one star, but both soles grip well, both dry and wet. The Ultra Raptor also has good grip, but there was more noticeable wear compared to the other shoes in this test, so I'm concerned about its lack of durability.

From left: inov-8, Hoka one one, La Sportiva, Columbia Montrail, Merrell

cushion

The Speedgoat 3 is overwhelming. It's no wonder they're called marshmallow shoes. Not only are they soft, but they also have just the right amount of resilience, so your power doesn't escape and thanks to the sled in the sole, it's converted into propulsion, propelling you forward. Damage reduction is particularly high on downhills. The Ultra Raptor is also a bit hard, but it has solid cushioning and reduces damage even on hard surfaces.

Each has its own distinctive features. The Speedgoat and Ultra Raptor have voluminous cushioning

The Speedgoat Ultra Raptor uses Ortholite insoles, which are also used by Salomon and Nike, the Caldorado III uses a fairly sturdy insole with arch support.

The insoles for each shoe. Caldorado's insoles even come with arch support

Stability

In terms of stability, the Ultra Raptor wins hands down. The overall hold of the shoe and the stability when you land are outstanding. With heel hold, reinforced sides of the upper, and toe protection, it's hard to give up this stability, even though it comes at the cost of lightness. It may not be enough on relatively easy trails, but it really shines on trails with lots of bumps and scree. The Momentus Caldorado III also provides a strong hold in the heel area, so it's very stable when you land.

Highly stable models have volume in the heel area and are well-made

summary

Unless you're a top athlete, comfort is crucial for long-distance running. No matter how good the cushioning and other performance features are, you'll be wearing the shoes for a very long time, so it's important to be able to wear them with as little stress as possible

Of the shoes reviewed this time, the ones that provided the most comfort were the inov-8 Terraultra G 260 and the Columbia Montrail Caldorado III . These two models have very flexible upper soles and good ventilation, so they were very comfortable to wear for long periods of time. You can't go wrong with these shoes.

However, in long-distance races, you will often be able to leave your luggage in a drop bag along the way. If you think of the shoes mentioned above as your standard shoes, and use a highly protective model like the Ultra Raptor when the road is rough and rocky, or a the Hoka one one Speedgoat 3 , being able to choose the right shoes based on the elevation change and road surface of the course will help you finish the race.

Shoes are a tool that can make up for your shortcomings and also help you develop what you already have. Choosing the right equipment for the race is one of the joys of long-distance races. If you take a look at yourself and your equipment on a regular basis, you'll naturally find the perfect shoes for you!

   

Related reading

Comparative review: Training shoes that allow beginners and veterans to run in the summer mountains [Short (20-50km)]

Comparison review: Barefoot, thick-soled... A professional trail writer compared the trail running shoes that were popular in 2018.

Comparison review: What are the recommended training shoes for Hasetsune? [Aim for Sub 10]

[A self-paying comparison review without any consideration] If you want to drive off-roading in a fun and comfortable way, this is the pair. Comparing actual trail running shoes for long distances