A leisurely comparison review: "I wish there was, but I don't need it" trekking gloves. If you choose, which one should you go?
Written by Aya Fujiwara
When you usually climb with veteran mountain friends, you will notice that surprisingly many people climb with their bare hands. but! I want to climb mountains, but I definitely don't want to get injured if it's a scuff! I am selfish in my heart and body. To prevent the cold at the top, there's no harm in having one trekking gloves. Especially for beginners who are not yet confident in their feet, or women with thin skin, it is worth wearing them. So up until now, I've been using a fine anti-slip extension that fits the hand, but I wanted something neat and neat, so I used four items to compare them.
This is my first contribution, with the editor-in-chief instructing me to write. This may be a bit disappointing for fans of the usual manly and extremely detailed reviews, with a high level of gear, but the autumn leaves season is currently in the middle of the year. If you like, we hope you will be able to join us like a travel report and liven up the outdoors. There is only a sense of respect for those who play in the stoic mountains, but it's also nice to take in the scenery at once! It would be a good idea to stuff a ping pong ball into your backpack and measure it, but from a woman's perspective it's a pretty strange sight (in a good way).
table of contents
table of contents
- First impressions: Basic specs to keep in mind first
- Compatibility diagnosis: Wearing test in the northern lands
- Final diagnosis: "Ame-Nemo Nekokezu" waterproof test
- Summary - When is it recommended? ~
First impressions: Basic specs to keep in mind first
When climbing or trekking, trekking gloves are actually something you don't need, but you don't need. So, we chose items with a variety of functions and materials, ranging from items that are easy to get, ranging from items with a price of ¥1,000 that are easy to get, to those that don't require a bit of a need for 5,000 units. Moreover, when I heard that the editor-in-chief was paying for it, I was completely at a loss for choosing something too expensive. However, a few days after informing me that I had selected three points, I received an additional item saying, "I would like you to try using this as well." Apparently the editor-in-chief is serious. Everyone, please support us.
This time, I took four trekking gloves on my traverse from Mt. Rausu to Mt. Io. This is a rather plain test, where the other members enjoy the spectacular views, replacing their gloves. Feelingly, I chose this with the intention of deciding on my partner for the future mountain climbing.
First, here are the basic specifications.
Specification comparison table
| Partner candidate 1 | Partner candidate 2 | Partner candidate 3 | Partner candidate 4 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| item |  finetrack Everbreast Trail Glove |  Foxfire Gravel Gripper |  PAINE Gore-Tex Trekking Gloves |  PUROMONTE Inner gloves |
| Reference price | 6,048 yen | 4,860 yen | 4,298 yen | 1,296 yen |
| weight | 30g | 70g | 57g | 40g |
| material | Front: 100% nylon, back: 100% polyester, inside: polyurethane laminate | Main material: Nylon material composition: 100% durable water-repellent stretch nylon, Liner: Aeroporous FW glove insert, Lining: 100% micro fleece polyester, Separate fabric: Synthetic leather | 100% nylon (GORE-TEX laminate) | 100% polyester + artificial leather |
| Main features | Waterproof and moisture permeability | Waterproof and heat retention | Windproof and moisture permeable | Heat retention, quick drying |
As the name suggests, Promonte is an extremely cheap, and can be used as an inner gloves in the winter and does not have any waterproof or windproof features.
It may not matter, but that's clear from looking at the tags.
While Fine Track and Foxfire are vocal about their waterproofing, Paine conveys the selling point of WIND STOPPER with bright red tags. Meanwhile, the Promonte tag, which does not use so-called functional materials, comes with a sticker that loosely says, "Warm and Fit! Perfect for trekking!" Personally, I find this Showa era feeling irresistible.
Compatibility diagnosis: Wearing test in the northern lands
"Climb Mount Fuji and talk about the height of the mountains. As Omachi Katsugetsu says, "Climbing Mt. Daisetsu and telling you the size of the mountains," but since mountains in Hokkaido cross many mountains to reach one peak, it takes quite a while to reach the summit, regardless of the altitude. The Tom Lauss, which I climbed last year, was a pretty tough trip for me, a Henna Choco Mountain Lady (I can't even call myself a girl anymore...). I was probably exhausted at the end this time, and thought I might forget to change my gloves... but somehow I started experimenting.
Thankfully, the weather was good for the two days in Hokkaido, so I would like to first report on the results of wearing it on clear sunny days.
Probable Partner 1: Finetrack Everbreast Trail Glove
The first thing you can tell is how light it is. Those who value UL may be a factor in making decisions. Even when you put it in your hand, you don't feel the so-called stiffness of the waterproof gloves, and it feels thinner and smoother than you imagined. However, the biggest neck is that the cuff does not have velcro. Although its suit is its selling point, it does not have a sense of stability on the wrist, making it a little unrequited. Since there is no velcro, it contains a strong elastic, making it a bit of a hassle to put on and take off. There is a possibility that rain could enter through your wrists, so although it's a hassle to do one step, I personally think it's better to have Velcro. Also, since they are basically ray gloves, even though they are made of breathable fabric, there is no denying that they feel a bit uncomfortable when worn on a sunny day. The grip isn't bad, but I got the impression that it's probably possible that you can experience a variety of effects when using it on a rainy day. I think it's also suitable for winter inner gloves.
Partner candidate 2: Foxfire Gravel Gripper
This one is also waterproof, but features a three-layer structure: a water-repellent shell, a breathable waterproof insert, and a sweat-absorbing quick-drying mesh liner. The difference is obvious when compared to Fine Track, which is made of a thin piece of fabric and is waterproof. To be honest, I thought it wasn't very comfortable to wear because it had a three-layer structure, but perhaps because the mesh liner was nice on the skin, it was even more comfortable than I imagined. However, when you hold the stock, it has a three-layered feel that it slips slightly in the middle, and it seems that the Fine Track has a higher grip. Some types have micro fleece liners, but they are still warm enough. By the way, of the four items I chose this time, this is the only type that allows you to use your smartphone while still on, but in reality, it's quite difficult to just press your PIN number. It may be that I'm clumsy, but it was quite difficult to keep this on and take out small items and prepare meals while still taking them on. I deliberately chose all black this time, but in terms of design, this one has the most modern feel.
Partner candidate 3: PAINE Gore-Tex Trekking Glove
Speaking of Paine, it is a well-known Ishii Sports original brand, but I have been wearing it for the last few hours since I tried out all four of the items on my mountain trip. The soft yet firm texture is like bonding, and it fits perfectly the moment you put it on. It is not the thickest and thinner of the four, but I didn't feel any discomfort from sweating and hardly felt stuffy. It has high grip and is very smooth to carry. Although the weather was big, I was able to wear it the most stress-free. There was quite a bit of wind at the top, but it was a truly impressive WINDSTOPPER. It releases sweat and protects the wind, so my hands are comfortable without getting cold. It's not waterproof, but it seems to be reasonably priced.
Partner candidate 4: PUROMONTE Inner gloves
Rather than being for trekking, it is easy to wear like a gloves for use in town. It's probably smart to wear it alone from spring to autumn, and use it as an inner gloves in winter. The light and warm material, like brushed fleece, is so comfortable that it feels great when you apply it! To improve the fit, the extremely thin fabric is used only on the gusset of the fingers, so the details are also paid attention to, making it extremely cost-effective. However, one thing that caught my eye about the design was that the velcro was on the inside of the wrist, not on the back of the hand. Although I didn't really bother me, I sometimes felt a bit tingling when I held the stock, so I was wondering why I simply put it inside. The grip is pretty good. However, there is some stuffiness when walking for a long time. Since we are not actively using functional materials, this is unavoidable considering the price. Also, the way he gets tired after descending the mountain was quite good. The rubbing has also caused some pilling, so it seems that it cannot be used for a long time.
Final diagnosis: "Ame-Nemo Nekokezu" waterproof test
So, personally, I would have fitted the PAINE on clear days, but the outdoor gear gin didn't finish here, and although it had already come down from the mountain, I also tested its waterproofness.
I wore gloves while wearing the cell, put on a weak shower over the top for 30 seconds while holding the stock, and looked at how much weight would change between the front and back (only one hand). After the shower, I thoroughly wipe off the moisture with a towel before measuring it.
Probable Partner 1: Finetrack Everbreast Trail Glove
14.6g → 15.3g ... 0.7g increase
No matter how much water is poured over this, you will feel a sense of security that it won't get wet. It may be different if the environment changes, but at least during the experiment it seemed like it was not stuffy at all. And most of all, I was impressed that the grip strength was almost completely different.
Partner candidate 2: Foxfire Gravel Gripper
30.4g → 32.5g ... 2.1g increase
When I wear it, huh? Are you getting soaked? I thought for a moment, but it was a strange feeling that I wasn't actually wet at all. In the end, the middle of the three-layer structure protects water, so it seems like the distance between the water is close. The non-slip part is wet on the surface, so it is likely that the weight changes. The grip is slightly reduced.
Partner candidate 3: PAINE Gore-Tex Trekking Glove
27g → 32.4g ... 5.4g increase
PAINE was my favorite when it was sunny, but since it was not waterproof, I could feel the water soaking gently. However, as you can see from the increased number of grams, it doesn't seem to be slurping, it feels like you're wearing damp gloves. It's not as comfortable as it is, but the grip was surprisingly strong.
Partner candidate 4: PUROMONTE Inner gloves
20.6g → 35.6g ... 15g increase
Water seeps into you in no time, and it's not so good in the mountains that you can't wear. It's a soft feel when it's sunny...
Summary - When is it recommended? ~
So, the results were exactly as I imagined, so I wondered if there was any point in doing so. There's no need to say it now, but isn't it just too amazing? Waterproof material! After all, the comfort while bathing in water is completely different. If you're a good-looking person who wants to take photos even in the rain, you should definitely choose waterproof.
As someone who is a must-have trekking gloves, if you're looking to buy just one, the PAINE is a good balance.
On days when you don't have to worry about the weather, I would like to use this child as my partner to enjoy a comfortable climb.
However, when the rain is suspicious, it's more reliable to have waterproof features, so Foxfire is likely to be useful. Climbing in the middle of summer is a bit less comfortable, but it's not a big deal to prepare for the rain in an emergency.
It seems that this model is also available in a warm type that is suitable for the coming season.
On the other hand, if you are taking measures to prepare for the upcoming winter climb, you should have some inner gloves ready. For such greedy people, we recommend Finetrack, which is highly waterproof and breathable. Especially when using it as an inner gloves, the lack of velcro on your wrist will be a great help.
If you're more concerned about feel and price than features, PUROMONTE is definitely the place to go! I think that even people who don't normally use trekking gloves can use them without any discomfort.
If you choose according to your climate and preferences, you may find it a problem if there is a trekking gloves that you definitely don't need, but don't need.
Fujiwara Aya
After working for a publishing company, he became a freelance editor/writer since 2007. She is active mainly in print media such as women's magazines, brand mooks, books, and catalogs. He works in a wide range of genres, including fashion, lifestyle and culture. In my private life, I opened my sight after happening to go to Migahara, and now my hobby is visiting nature all over Japan. From Hokkaido to Kagoshima, you will climb beautiful mountains, regardless of size, and view the magnificent waterfalls and soak in secret hot springs all over the country. He is currently searching for a move to the countryside.
Looking for reviewers
Outdoor Gearzine is always looking for members who love the outdoors and would like to write reviews about outdoor equipment. For more information, please this REVIEWERS page !
